Skip to main content

NewFolks may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

The Best Crib Sheets To Help Your Baby Sleep in Bliss

best crib sheet
Thomas Bullock / Getty

Picture this: your little one, all cozied up in their crib, wrapped in layers of soft, breathable goodness. Such a serene scene is possible with the right bedding for your baby’s crib, starting with the sheets. The right sheets for you little one’s bed can make all the difference in making them feel comfy and safe. Carefully crafted from the gentlest materials, crib sheets provide a soft surface for your baby’s delicate skin.

Do you want to know the best part? Sheets specifically designed for cribs fit snugly, minimizing risks and ensuring  safe, worry-free sleep. Let’s dive into our list of the best crib sheets of 2024, starting with my absolute favorite product: Newton Baby’s Organic Fitted Crib Sheets. We’ll unravel the details regarding thread count, breathability, and whether organic is worth it or not. Let’s dive in!

newton baby crib sheet

Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheets – Best Overall

Buy Now

The Newton Baby Organic Fitted Crib Sheet redefines what it means to have a cozy and safe sleeping environment for your little one. Crafted from 100% organic muslin cotton, this sheet delivers an unmatched level of softness, ensuring your baby’s comfort throughout the night. What truly makes it stand out is its meticulous design, which guarantees a snug, wrinkle-free fit on all standard cribs. This means no more worries about loose sheets posing a safety hazard for your baby while they sleep.

Even better, this sheet is exceptionally breathable, promoting healthy airflow and reducing the risk of overheating. And unlike other companies, Newton Baby prioritizes your baby’s skin comfort by providing a gentle, irritation-free touch. If you ask me, it’s this combination of breathability, softness, and a perfect fit that makes this crib sheet the best overall choice for your baby to enjoy peaceful and safe sleep night after night.


  • Available in 13 colors
  • All-around elastic for a secure fit
  • Made with pre-shrunk organic muslin cotton
  • Fits standard-sized, 8-inch thick mattresses


  • Sheets are thinner than expected
my little north star crib sheet

My Little North Star Baby Crib Sheet – Most Durable

Buy Now

The My Little North Star Baby Crib Sheet is a game-changer in the world of baby bedding, thanks to its exceptional quality and unmatched softness. Made from pure, organic cotton, this sheet provides a cozy and comforting environment for your little one to rest and recharge. What sets it apart is not just its softness, but also its durability and wash-friendly design that withstands countless cycles without losing quality or softness. Meanwhile, the snug fit on standard cribs and toddler mattresses alike ensures that the sheet will stay in place, all without any ruffles or creases. Even more, the fact that it comes in a pack of two means you’ll haves a convenient backup for inevitable baby messes. Think of this sheet as more than just a bedding accessory; it is an essential addition to your baby’s nursery that offers up a cozy and comfortable environment for your little one to relax, rest, and grow.


  • Made from 100% organic jersey cotton
  • Hypoallergenic, breathable, and snug-fitting
  • 360-degree elastic keeps the sheets from slipping
  • Fits standard crib and toddler mattresses


  • May get damaged easily
yoofoss crib sheet

Yoofoss Crib Sheet – Best for Crib-To-Bed Transition

Buy Now

Transitioning your little one from a crib to a toddler bed can be challenging, but the Yoofoss Baby Crib Sheet makes it a breeze. First off, you’re sure to love how easy it is to clean. Crafted from super soft microfiber, this sheet resists stubborn stains and can be machine-washed, ensuring your baby’s sleeping environment stays fresh and hygienic. The fabric snugly embraces the mattress, maintaining a smooth surface that promises your child will enjoy restful, uninterrupted sleep.

Not only does this sheet prioritize practicality, but it also add a touch of aesthetics. Available in a pack of two, it comes in a variety of colors and patterns that’ll add a bit of whimsy to your child’s room. And since it fits standard crib and toddler mattresses perfectly, this sheet will cover the mattress without any creases or loose ends. As a whole, its thoughtful design, combined with the soft fabric, promotes comfortable sleep and can make the crib-to-toddler bed transition less daunting.


  • Comes in seven colors and patterns
  • Soft, durable microfiber construction
  • Features a 7-inch deep pocket
  • Won’t lose its shape after washing


  • Prone to showing stains
burts bees crib sheet

Burt’s Bees Baby Organic Cotton Crib Sheet – Best Style Options

Buy Now

Crafted from 100% organic cotton, the Burt’s Bees Baby Organic Cotton Crib Sheet wraps your baby in gentle comfort, akin to the feel of your favorite tee. This sheet fits into standard cribs and toddler mattresses, and it’s both durable and soft. It can withstand repeated washing while still maintaining its super-soft texture. Beyond providing parents with undeniable quality, this pick ensures that their baby’s sleep environment is as wholesome as possible.

My favorite thing has to be the array of unique patterns, ranging from moons to elephants and more, that infuse your nursery with a touch of charm and sweetness. This, combined with the product’s organic construction, makes the sheet blend with any nursery decor while prioritizing your baby’s well-being. Even better, with its GOTS certification, parents can rest assured they have chosen a sheet that’s as good for the planet as it is for their baby. Whether you’re choosing it for your own baby or a friend’s, this sheet provides the ideal balance between comfort, quality, and style.


  • Available in a wide variety of unique patterns
  • Made of 100% GOTS-certified organic cotton
  • Durable enough to prevent pilling
  • A great choice for sensitive skin


  • May fit some mattresses too tightly
blissful diary crib sheet

Blissful Diary Muslin Crib Sheet – Most Comfortable

Buy Now

Elevate your baby’s sleep with the Blissful Diary Muslin Crib Sheet — a stunning blend of style, comfort, and convenience. Designed for both girls and boys, this sheet fits snugly on standard crib and toddler bed mattresses, creating a comfortable, soft, and breathable surface for your baby to rest. And because it’s crafted from premium-quality muslin cotton, the sheets feel luxuriously soft against your baby’s skin, ensuring a night of restful sleep.

The fitted crib sheets pack boasts six stylish designs featuring solid colors and soothing patterns. These sheets redefine your baby’s sleeping environment, turning sleep into a smooth, uninterrupted journey into dreamland. Plus, with their neutral color palette, the sheets effortlessly blend into any nursery decor. Personally, I’d say they do so much more than cover your mattress; they cradle your baby in a cocoon of softness and warmth, inviting blissful dreams.


  • Available in multiple colors and patterns
  • Crafted from muslin cotton
  • 360-degree elastic band provides a secure fit
  • Double-layer fabric design adds durability


  • Too loose on some mattresses
best crib sheet
Media Trading Ltd / Getty

Buying Guide: Crib Sheets

Selecting the ideal crib sheet for your baby might feel like a puzzle with so many styles, materials, and safety aspects to juggle. You might be asking yourself, “Where do I even start?” Well, think of this guide as your friendly companion through the realm of crib sheets, offering down-to-earth tips to ensure you pick the best one for your little one’s comfort and safety. Let’s dive in!


When I was searching for crib sheets, I realized how crucial it was to consider the material. One of the most popular choices is cotton because of its softness and breathability, which ensures your baby stays comfortable throughout the night. If you’re in a warmer climate, muslin would be an excellent option as it’s a lightweight cotton fabric that helps regulate your baby’s body temperature. On the other hand, if you live in a colder environment, flannel sheets would provide the necessary warmth and comfort.

Size and Fit

Size matters more than you’d think. Why? Well, ill-fitting sheets can be dangerous for babies and may even lead to suffocation. Acrib sheet’s standard size is 52 by 28 inches, which should fit most crib mattresses; however, it’s always a good idea to measure your mattress before buying to make sure you get the right size. You should also look for sheets with elastic edges that can provide a more secure fit and prevent loose corners.


As a parent, I know that my baby’s comfort is crucial for their health. When selecting sheets for my baby’s crib, I recommend choosing ones that feel soft and gentle on their delicate skin. Also, be sure to consider the sheet’s thickness to balance cushioning and breathability. Remember, a comfortable baby is a healthier baby.


To ensure your crib sheets last long, choose high-quality materials with robust construction that won’t fray, pill, or fade after frequent washing. Check the seams for sturdiness and consistency, and go for cotton with a high thread count or blends for durability and softness.

Safety Standards

When selecting crib sheets, it is important to prioritize safety. The sheets you choose should be free from harmful chemicals, dyes, and flame retardants that could potentially cause skin irritation or allergies for your baby. It’s recommended that you look for sheets that have been certified by organizations such as OEKO-TEX Standard 100 or Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), as this indicates that the sheets have met high safety and environmental standards.


It can be tempting to choose the cheapest option when purchasing sheets, but it’s important to keep in mind that the price is often a reflection of the quality. While investing in higher-priced sheets may offer better comfort, durability, and safety to some degree, it’s important not to overspend unnecessarily. The key is to find a balance between cost and quality that fits within your budget.

Common Questions About Crib Sheets

What is the best material for crib sheets?

When it comes to crib sheets, you can choose from different materials, such as cotton, flannel, or fleece. Cotton is very breathable and easy to maintain, while flannel and fleece offer greater softness and warmth. It’s essential to consider your climate and the comfort your baby requires to choose the right fabric for your crib sheet.

How often should I change crib sheets?

It’s recommended to change crib sheets at least once a week or whenever they get dirty or stained. We’d also recommend keeping a few sets on hand so you can change them more frequently if needed.

How do I wash crib sheets?

Crib sheets can be washed in warm water with a gentle detergent. Always check the care label for specific washing instructions. To prevent shrinkage, dry on low heat or air-dry.

Are all crib sheets the same size?

No, crib sheets come in different sizes to fit different mattresses. Standard crib sheets usually fit a mattress of 52 x 28 inches. Always measure your mattress before buying a crib sheet to ensure a snug fit.

Why is it important for crib sheets to fit snugly?

Loose crib sheets can pose a suffocation hazard for babies. A well-fitting crib sheet is safer because it stays in place, even if your baby moves around in the crib.

Can crib sheets shrink after washing?

Yes, especially if they are made of cotton. That’s why it’s important to follow the care instructions and use a gentle washing cycle and low heat to dry. In fact, some crib sheets are pre-shrunk to minimize this issue.

Editors' Recommendations

Carey Schaal
Writer and Editor
From Louisiana, with degrees in psychology and business, I blend design and parenting insights into consumer content.
The best baby bottle warmers in 2024
best baby bottle warmer 2024

It’s important for babies to consume warm drinks to mimic the temperature of breast milk and allow for easier digestion for your young baby. Baby bottle warmers are a safe and convenient way to heat bottles or your infant. Our list of the best baby bottle warmers begins with Momcozy.
Top Baby Bottle Warmers

Momcozy Bottle Warmer - Best Overall
Buy Now

Read more
The Best Baby Monitors of 2024
Smiling woman having coffee in kitchen using phone to monitor her sleeping baby

If you're a stressed out new parent, a baby monitor is a must have. Baby monitors make your life much easier by giving you peace of mind that your baby is safe, even when they aren't by your side. We reviewed a wide variety of the best baby monitors including modern wifi monitors and trusty, reliable no-wifi monitors. In our reviews, we considered factors like video/audio quality, battery life, security features, and more. After all this research, we chose the Ellie Baby Pro Baby Monitor as our favorite baby monitor on the market. Keep reading to see the rest of our picks.
Comparing the Best Best Baby Monitors of 2024
Ellie Baby Pro Breathing Detection Baby Monitor - Best Overall


Read more
Help teens deal with breakouts and acne: Top tips for your adolescent to work through this common skin issue
Is your teen struggling with acne? Here's how to help
Profile of teen boy struggling with acne

Pimples and adolescence certainly seem to go hand in hand. According to WebMD, 85% of teenagers struggle with acne. While acne and recurrent breakouts are widespread in tweens and teens, there are factors that contribute to the common skin problem.

Genetics and hormones are two of the main causes of acne. If you battled breakouts as a teenager, then your teen most likely will as well. When puberty hits, the changes tweens and teens experience in their hormones are the major contributors to breakouts and acne. Stress and anxiety also play a role, which is why those pimples always seem to crop up right before the homecoming dance or a speech. Moms have said it for years and teens don't necessarily listen, but diet has a hand, too. Medication and makeup can also cause breakouts and acne.

Read more