Skip to main content

Cloth vs. disposable diapers: Which is really the best choice?

Diapers — can’t live with them, can’t live without ’em. (But really though, you can’t live without them when you have a newborn, infant, or toddler.) The reality is, diapers are both a blessing and an inconvenience. They ensure that your home isn’t perpetually covered in pee and poop, but they can cost a small fortune and clog landfills. With this in mind, many prospective and new parents consider using cloth diapers as a more budget-friendly, Earth-conscious option. Of course, this alternative isn’t always the ideal, either. To cloth or not to cloth — that is the question. You’ll want to consider the benefits and drawbacks of both reusable and disposable diapers — and determine which is a better fit for your lifestyle. Let’s break it down.

diaper change with cloth diaper
Goncharov_Artem/Shutterstock

Cloth diapers vs. disposable diapers

The pros and cons of cloth diapers are both plentiful. Faithfully choosing reusable is quite a commitment. There are several things you’ll want to keep in mind. Of course, on the flip side, disposable diapers can be great, but they certainly aren’t perfect, either. Here are the biggest distinguishing factors:

Material Choices

Cloth diapers: These reusable diapers come in various materials, so you can go with cotton, terry, or another soft fabric of your choosing. You can try a simple cloth liner option that needs to be folded and secured or a fitted one that’s ready to use (it looks like a traditional disposable diaper.) Either way, you can feel good knowing that there are no harsh chemicals or dyes in your diaper of choice.

Disposable diapers: Of course, there are a variety of options to choose from, but the outside of most disposable diapers are made with polyethylene film and polypropylene. The absorbent inside is made of chemical compounds that can effectively absorb urine, and the whole thing is often bleached in chlorine. In other words, they’re not the most “natural” item to put against Baby’s bare bum. Nevertheless, most pediatricians say that they’re perfectly safe.

Winner: Cloth diapers are chemical-free and super soft on Baby’s sensitive skin.

Expense

Cloth diapers: Sure, you have to shell out a bit more at first when investing in a set of cloth diapers. Soon enough, though, you’ll be thankful you did. Disposable diapers are a huge expense and add up quickly; if you are on a very tight budget, cloth diapers may be the way to go.

Disposable diapers: Better start saving up now; you are going to go through diapers like they are going out of style. Newborns typically need to be changed between eight and 10 times a day. That can mean up to 70 diaper changes in the first week alone. Of course, things slow down a bit as Baby grows and gets a bit older, but you’ll still need a significant budget for your weekly or monthly boxes (yes, buying in bulk helps a bit!).

Winner: Cloth diapers will save you a bundle!

Protection

Cloth diapers: To be honest, most cloth diapers do a fair job of absorbing, catching, and holding your little one’s pees and poops. However, they’re definitely not made to allow for any, um, marinating time. This means you’ll be changing Baby more often.

Disposable diapers: If you have an active lifestyle, you’ll be happy to know that most disposable diapers will keep your cutie-pie protected. That absorbent chemical inside holds more urine and allows you to go a wee bit longer between changes.

Winner: Disposable diapers will hold more and keep Baby drier for longer.

disposable diaper change
Robert Kneschke/ Shutterstock

Convenience

Cloth diapers: We’re not going to lie — this is more like an “inconvenience” factor. When you’re on the go, cloth diapers are not exactly low-maintenance. You’ll need to have a system for bagging and transporting, and eventually washing. It’s a process; if you choose to use cloth diapers, you might consider the occasional disposable or two for car trips, errand-heavy days, and even bedtime changes.

Disposable diapers: One and done — throw that puppy in the garbage and move on with your day. No mess, smelly laundry accumulating, and no worries. To this end, disposable options streamline the overall diaper-changing process.

Winner: Disposable diapers are much more convenient for busy parents.

Eco-friendly factor

Cloth diapers: If you care about Mother Nature and want to do your part to contribute to the greater good with a less-impactful carbon footprint, cloth diapers are the way to go.

Disposable diapers: Sorry to say that these bad boys are not so great for our Earth. Disposable diapers add millions of tons of waste to landfills every year — so you may want to weigh your individual needs with those of our planet.

Winner: Cloth diapers are undoubtedly a more Earth-friendly option.

Clearly, both reusable cloth diapers and disposable options have their benefits and drawbacks. Ultimately, one isn’t better than the other. Your choice needs to be motivated by your individual needs — and that of your baby. You’re also not limited to one or the other. You can choose to switch back and forth between the two depending on your schedule. There’s no right or wrong here — find what works for you and go with it.

Editors' Recommendations

Lauren Barth
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Lauren Barth is a freelance writer and digital editor with over a decade of experience creating lifestyle, parenting, travel…
The dirty truth about cloth diapers
This is how many cloth diapers you really need

Using cloth diapers can sound daunting and leave you asking a lot of questions. How many cloth diapers do you need? How often do you change cloth diapers? How do you clean cloth diapers? How much do cloth diapers cost? Getting started can seem so tough that you might just go disposable for convenience. Discovering the answers to these questions may reveal that cloth is the better choice for you.

There is a lot to learn when preparing for a new baby and deciding between cloth and disposable diapers is one big decision worth researching. Thankfully, we've put all of the answers to your questions in one place. Once you get started with cloth diapers, you don't have to keep buying new diapers over and over again. Let's dive into the honest answers to all of your cloth diaper questions.

Read more
Waterproof bibs may not be your best choice – here’s why
A baby wearing a bib.

Bibs are an essential item for babies, and bibs are optimal for toddlers, too (especially because they're messy). There are several types of bibs out there, and you've probably heard of waterproof bibs — after all, these have gained in popularity in recent years. But what do you know about this style of bibs? Do you know enough to consider this sort for your child?

Waterproof bibs are made of a plastic coating or laminate to keep dribble and food off your baby. Silicone bibs are also waterproof and just as helpful during meals. However, waterproof bibs with a plastic coating or backing may not be the best choice for your little one. If cared for incorrectly, the waterproof quality on these bibs breaks down and leaves a regular bib behind. For this reason and others, you may want to rethink waterproof bibs.
Waterproof bibs require special wash settings
What makes waterproof bibs different from other types? Waterproof bibs are made differently than traditional bibs thanks to their special materials. They’re constructed with different materials or fabrics that make them waterproof. First, polyester fabrics with a plastic coating are popular choices. The coating makes the front waterproof while the back is made of a softer fabric for your baby’s comfort.

Read more
The best and safest pacifiers for babies and toddlers
Baby holding pacifier

Pacifiers are a part of most babies' lives and will likely also be a part of your baby's life. If you're a parent who prefers not to give your infant bottles or breastfeed at bedtime (or if you're weaning them from nighttime feeding), then pacifiers are even more likely.

But know that some babies don't like pacifiers no matter what shape they are or what type of sweetener you may put on them. However, for most infants, they are favorite soothing devices that are acceptable until between ages 2 and 4 when parents are encouraged to wean their babies from pacifiers to avoid possible dental problems.

Read more