Skip to main content

Why you can leave the toddler formula on the supermarket shelf

Is toddler formula a parent’s best friend or an unnecessary foe? And should parents be stocking up on this product as their little ones quickly approach the toddler phase of life? If you’ve seen toddler formula on the shelves of your local supermarket or talked about on a blog you follow on social media, we’re here to dish on the pros and cons of the product and whether parents need to add it to their pantry shelves.

Amorn Suriyan/shutterstock

What is toddler formula?

Available from a wide variety of top infant formula companies such as Gerber, Earth’s Life and Enfamil, toddler formula is marketed toward parents with kids ages 9 months through 3 years of age. Sometimes referred to as toddler transitions formula or toddler milk, toddler formula is essentially a mixture of powdered milk, various sweeteners and cold-pressed vegetable oil. It’s because of these ingredients that most parents – and pediatricians – do not recommend using this product for toddlers.

One theory behind avoiding toddler formula involves children becoming used to receiving the formula and outright refusing or showing aversion towards cow’s milk — and other versions of dairy and non-dairy milks – in the future. The addition of sweeteners to the powdered milk in toddler formula is also a cause for concern in parent groups and physician’s offices.

Is toddler formula safe?

While not outright dangerous for the children who may consume it, toddler milk is something that is not regulated and monitored like its infant formula counterpart. In the case of infants and infant brand formulas, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) oversees the labeling and checks in with companies for quality and accuracy. Toddler milk does not fall under that category and does not receive the same rigorous safety and quality tests.


When should toddler milk be used?

There are certain situations when toddler milk can be a great supplement to cow’s milk, especially for little ones who suffer from allergies or other dietary restrictions. These kiddos have most likely been recommended to use the product by their pediatrician or attending physician. When these products are used by parents for their children, under the direction of a doctor, toddler milk can be a valuable asset to parents’ pantries. Toddler formulas are typically introduced to children around the same time they would be weaned from infant formula or breastmilk – around the age of one. Although this product could be used after its recommended age of 3 years, doing so should only be done under the direction of your child’s pediatrician.

What other choices do parents have?

If your sweet little tot is approaching their toddler phase sooner rather than later, parents will often discuss their options with their child’s pediatrician to decide a game plan for transition. While some moms choose to breastfeed their child well into their terrible two’s and beyond, others begin to introduce whole cow’s milk around the age of 12 months. Parents can supplement cow’s milk, starting with one cup a day, while slowly increasing the amount until the toddler is completely weaned from their previous nutrition – either infant formula or breastmilk. The recommended kind of cow’s milk for toddlers who can tolerate it is whole, due to it’s added vitamin D and high levels of calories and calcium.

Be careful and tread lightly on the quantity of cow’s milk your child receives daily. Consuming too much can lead to your toddler’s exacerbated hunger, due to their bodies needing to consume more solid foods and less milk as they get older. Having nutrient-rich varieties of fruits, veggies, cheese, meats, nuts and dairy products (if tolerated) are also key and important elements to your toddler’s diet.

Consult your pediatrician

If your child has reached the age where you are considering the weaning process, but you’re not sure if the cans of toddler formula found on your grocery store’s shelves are the product needed to get the job done, we highly recommend speaking with your child’s pediatrician first. Opening the door of communication about nutrition and diet to your child’s doctor can unlock elements of knowledge that you might otherwise miss. Your little one’s physician should be well versed in your child’s needs and familiar with any medical or family history factors that could play into what kind of formula/breastmilk replacement product should be used. Often, it’s only recommended in situations that absolutely require it to be, such as a disability or allergy. Additionally, and according to the American Academy of Pediatrics, there is no known evidence to say that toddler formula is better than whole milk in the area of growth and development.

Editors' Recommendations

Emily Pidgeon
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Emily's work has appeared in the Tube City Almanac, Tube City Online and our Affinity Sites. When she's not writing, she is…
Need to clean out the playroom? This is where you should donate toys
Need help on where to donate toys to tidy up your child's room? We have the local spots to go to first
A child's room that's a bit messy with toys and items all over

Between holidays, birthdays, and "just because" moments, the playroom and kids' bedrooms fill up pretty quickly with all sorts of items. If you want to declutter that toy room and get rid of the things your children no longer play with, donating will teach your kids to help others while letting you see the floor again. Instead of the places that are the usual stops for toy donations near you, try these other places first.
Local Buy Nothing group
If you don't know about your local Buy Nothing group, please look into it. It's a safe place to swap, give away, or ask for items or services completely free of charge. Sure, we'd all like to get a few bucks back from our child's toys, but if you don't want to go through that hassle, this is the best option. You don't even have to leave the house if you're more comfortable with porch pickups in your neighborhood.
Ask hospitals what they could use
Hospitals have tighter rules about what they can take, but it's never a bad idea to ask. The hospital would be the best for when you purchased something, it was the wrong size or item, and now you can't return it. Though items still in the packaging and with tags are always preferred, there are exceptions. Call and ask what your local hospital would take.
Reach out to local day cares/schools
If your children have ever gone to day care, you know how quickly they ask for donations. Day cares are open to more kinds of things, not just toys, so if you need to do a bit of an overhaul in your kids' rooms, ask your local day care facilities. The schools in your area are a great go-to, as well. Teachers always need classroom supplies, and the younger grades would need toys, books, and even clothing for when accidents happen.
Parent groups
Whether you're in a bunch of Facebook groups or are part of a group that meets in person, ask people you already know if they could use some toys your children have outgrown. You have a rapport with these other parents, and if you meet up in person, you could bring the items along and not have to make another stop.

Women's and children's centers in your area
For your donations to make a bigger impact, make sure women's and children's centers are on your list. If you were a struggling parent, you know how much it means to have a place like that to go to when in need. If you're a parent who doesn't have to struggle, pay it forward and count your blessings by donating to one.

Read more
10 treats for your toddler’s Easter eggs that aren’t candy
Fill your child's Easter eggs with these alternatives to sweets
A boy and girl having fun during an Easter egg hunt

Before you know it, the Easter Bunny will be hopping down the bunny trail, much to the excitement of toddlers far and near. That means it's time to get those Easter baskets and plastic eggs ready because it’s egg hunt time. Whether the egg hunt is in the backyard, park, or at school, little kids love participating in the fun activity. Parents, however, could do without the sugar rush that comes with all those chocolaty treats.

The good news is that Easter egg fillers for toddlers don’t always have to be chocolate and candy. There are a lot of fun alternatives to those sweet treats that make great surprises for your kids. Here are 10 treats for your toddler's Easter eggs that aren’t candy.

Read more
What is implantation bleeding like? Facts you should know about when and why this happens
Implantation bleeding vs. period bleeding: Find out the difference
A menstrual pad being held on a pink background

Heavy implantation bleeding isn't typical, but we have the answers on what is normal for implantation bleeding. What is the difference between implantation bleeding vs. period bleeding and other questions you have about implantation will all be addressed, so that you can understand what this relatively uncommon phenomenon is like.

What is implantation bleeding like?
Implantation bleeding is very light bleeding, similar to a period (in the sense that it comes out of the vaginal canal from the uterus) that happens earlier than a period would come and lasts less than two days. It can be light pink or rust brown, but it's not usually the bright or dark red that period blood can be. Implantation doesn't have any clots and can be like spotting, a light flow, or just one or two smears of blood.
Implantation bleeding is just one possible symptom of implantation, so cramping, backaches, nausea, mood swings, sore breasts, bloating, fatigue, or headaches can accompany it.

Read more