Skip to main content

Is overfeeding a newborn a thing? You might be surprised by the answer

Cues to watch out for to let you know if you're overfeeding a newborn

Mother holding baby in nursery.
FamVeld / Shutterstock

Bringing baby home from the hospital comes with a laundry list of new responsibilities and questions. Besides the sleep schedule, many new parents may be worried about whether their infant is getting enough to eat. But, is going the other direction something parents should also worry about? Is there such a thing as overfeeding a newborn? The short answer is yes. Overfeeding a newborn is a possibility, but it doesn’t happen often.

Every newborn has differences in appetite where one might drink a bottle or breastfeed longer than another. Before you stress, don’t worry. There are signs to be on the lookout for when it comes to giving your little one too much food. Whether it’s your first or third child, if you are concerned about overfeeding your newborn, we have the information you need to know.

Mom breastfeeds baby and Dad watches.
paulaphoto / Shutterstock

Why overfeeding a newborn is something you don’t want to do

You and your infant are just getting to know one another. So, it is easy to wonder whether you’re feeding your infant enough or too much, especially if you’re breastfeeding. Feeding a newborn too much is a little different from when toddlers or kids overeat. Overfeeding a newborn often causes discomfort to the infant because a baby can’t properly digest all the breast milk or formula so quickly.

When overeating, the child ingests extra air, which may produce gas, increase abdominal discomfort, or cause crying. A child could spit up more than usual and have a softer stool. Although the discomfort of crying is not colic, babies cry more frequently than a child who already has colic. You’ll need to watch for the signs of overfeeding your baby so there isn’t a cranky person — newborn or otherwise — in the home.

Mom looking at bottle to see if baby has drank enough.
Miljan Zivkovic / Shutterstock

How to tell if your newborn is full

Unlike an older child who can tell you he or she isn’t hungry, newborns can’t verbalize the fact it’s not time to eat. So, parents need to rely on the nonverbal cues from their infant. Watch for these signals to clue you into whether your baby is full.

  • Turns away from the breast or bottle.
  • Takes longer breaks between sucking or slows down when sucking.
  • Baby gives out a wet burp.
  • Baby gets the hiccups.
  • Baby relaxes his or her body.
  • Baby falls asleep.

The amount of food each newborn needs will vary, but there are signs that generally show a baby is gaining enough nutrition, such as a happy demeanor and good muscle tone. On the other hand, overfeeding a newborn means the baby consumes more breast milk or formula than they need for growth. Getting too much milk overloads a child’s small stomach and consequently gets in the way of proper digestion.

Mom breastfeeding newborn in bed.
Nina Buday / Shutterstock

Signs of overfeeding a newborn on a regular basis

If you’re constantly overfeeding your baby, there will be signs. Be on the lookout for these red flags in your infant if you’re concerned about overfeeding.

  • Above-average weight gain
  • Frequent, nauseating bowel movements
  • Large burping
  • Milk regurgitation
  • Irritability
  • Sleep disturbance

Symptoms associated with overfeeding are usually mistaken for colic, reflux, allergies, or intolerances to milk protein, or lactose intolerances. What separates the overeating from these conditions is that your child shows healthy growth, which does not happen when he or she has a digestive issue or a food allergy. You want your nugget to gain weight healthily, but too much weight gain too fast with these other symptoms could show your baby is getting too much to eat.

Baby drinking from a bottle.
Kolosov Alexandr / Shutterstock

What causes a newborn to eat too much?

There are plenty of reasons a newborn overeats. Not only is your child a new baby, learning how to live on this side of the womb, but they are trying to figure out how to do new things every single day. Sometimes signals get mixed and they think they are hungry when something else is really going on.

Sleep deprivation

Lack of sleep disrupts the hormonal balance, which regulates appetite, resulting in increased appetite. Before adding another feeding, try a little nap.


Babies are at the stage of oral development. In addition to wanting to suck when they are hungry, they also like to suck when they are tired, bored, uncomfortable, frustrated, or simply because they want to.

Active sucking reflex

Babies have a limited ability to stop when they’ve had enough milk due to the sucking reflex, especially when feeding quickly.

Fast feeding

Eating too quickly increases the likelihood that a child will ingest more milk than the stomach could hold, or more than their tiny digestive system could adequately digest.

Association of feeding and sleep

A child who falls asleep regularly by sucking a bottle learns that the way to fall asleep is with a bottle in their mouth. This means a child may want a bottle not only when they are hungry, but also when they are tired.

Ignoring the signs of satiety

Satiety means the child is full. The caregiver may try to force the child to consume the amount in the bottle after the child has shown signs of being full. Forced feeding of the baby is easy to implement while the baby’s sucking reflex is active during the birth to four-month period, and therefore it is easy to force the baby to take more than necessary.

Baby drinking from a bottle.
Lucy Wolski / Unsplash

Learn about overfeeding a newborn

For starters, it is important not to limit the baby’s milk intake, but to help them to self-regulate. If you happen to overload the baby, don’t stress too much. In the future, you would need to watch for signs of being full. If baby moves away before the end of the bottle or before the usual time of breastfeeding ends, then your baby is saying the feeding was enough.

Learn the cues your baby is hungry as well as the cues that tell you baby is full. Parents also need to know the reasons a baby overeats so they will be able to know situations where they shouldn’t force a feeding.

Mother feeding her baby a bottle.
Ariel Skelley / Getty Images

Signs your newborn is getting enough formula or breast milk

Just like there are signals when you’re overfeeding a newborn, there are signs with your baby that tell you they are getting fed enough. Be on the lookout for these telltale signs if you’re concerned about whether your baby is drinking enough formula or breast milk.

  • Steady weight gain is a sign your baby is getting enough milk.
  • A satisfied infant looks happy and at ease after eating.
  • Baby will open their hands and their body will become relaxed.
  • Peaceful sleeping is a good indicator of a baby that’s not overeating.
  • Wet diapers that don’t contain dark or strong-smelling urine.
  • Regular bowel movements.
Dad feeding his newborn with a bottle.
Anna Kraynova / Shutterstock

When baby is overfed, switch up the approach to feeding

Overfeeding a newborn is rare, but it happens. When feeding your baby, don’t focus on the amount because the quantity varies with each feeding. After all, you’ll be able to tell if your child is healthy and happy with certain baby cues.

Breastfed and formula-fed babies do have different eating habits, but it could happen to anyone, no matter how they feed their newborn. The main thing is to remember to remain calm. Keep a level head so you can assess your baby properly.

  • Try to keep to a feeding schedule – Maintaining the same time baby eats will help regulate their digestion, the same as it will yours.
  • Try paced bottle feeding – It’s easy to go on autopilot when feeding baby, especially when you are tired from having a newborn. But try to pay attention to the amount your baby is sucking down by controlling the angle of the bottle for the whole feeding.
  • Don’t force feeding time – Again, don’t force the feed. If baby isn’t hungry, they aren’t hungry. If they aren’t sick or have any other symptoms, they will eat when they are ready.
Mom feeding her baby outside.
Barbara Sauder / Shutterstock

If you want to talk to your doctor, go ahead

Keep an eye out for overfeeding a newborn, and when in doubt, call your pediatrician. Since the signs of overeating can mimic other conditions in infants like allergies or colic, it’s important to talk to your pediatrician. Your doctor can examine the baby’s growth and development, taking into account the symptoms you’ve been noticing at home to determine whether you are overfeeding your newborn.

You have to find a balance between making sure your baby is well-fed and making sure you don’t overfeed them, so they don’t have an upset stomach, diarrhea, or other tummy problems. Parenting is hard and being (and having) a newborn is just as challenging. You’re doing great as a parent, and you will get through this and be on to the next stage in no time.

Editors' Recommendations

Need to move things along? You can actually make prune juice for babies
Prune juice works for adults, but is it good for babies, too?
Mother comforting a crying baby

Prunes act as a natural laxative. The fruit is often used when adults and kids have difficulty going to the bathroom. As a parent, constipation is a major source of concern especially when it comes to babies. When babies get constipated parents often feel helpless, not knowing what to do to provide relief.
If you need some help to move things along, you may want to try a homemade remedy like prune juice for babies. Prune juice is a natural solution that's quick and easy to make at home. The important question to ask before heading to the blender though is prune juice safe for babies?

Signs of constipation in babies
Prune juice for babies is an option when little ones are constipated, but it's a good idea to know what you're dealing with before considering using prunes as a laxative for your kiddo. As an adult, it's simple to recognize when you're constipated, but what are the symptoms when a baby has difficulty pooping?

Read more
Can babies have nightmares? What you need to know
How to help your baby when they have a bad dream
Toddler being comforted in bed after a nightmare.

Can babies have nightmares? It may seem unlikely that your little one may be experiencing bad dreams, but if your baby has woken up crying for no apparent reason, you may wonder if a nightmare was the cause.

Often when we think of nightmares, we think of how they're subconsciously caused by our fears, or by something scary we may have watched on television. Since babies aren't watching scary movies and are mostly exposed to positive and comforting stimuli, parents often wonder if babies can have nightmares and what they can do to help soothe them back to sleep. We shed some light on why your baby may be waking up upset and what you can do to make their nights as peaceful as possible.

Read more
How much does the tooth fairy pay? The answer may shock you
Average tooth fairy rate per tooth
Tooth smile with missing tooth

Losing baby teeth is one of the most exciting milestones for many children and one that also gives many parents a bit of anxiety. If the tooth fairy is a tradition in your home, you may find yourself scrambling for cash at the last minute and wondering just how much the tooth fairy pays these days! Things have changed since parents lost their own baby teeth, and the going rate for those pearly whites has definitely increased. While you can (of course) give whatever you want, kids at school will be discussing what the tooth fairy gave them and if the number is different, there could be confusion or disappointment.

It's best to be prepared when deciding how much the tooth fairy will give for a tooth at your home by knowing what the average rate the tooth fairy gives out nationally is.

Read more